Children are dying from abandoned U.S. explosives
Published on April 10, 2014
As the U.S. military withdraws from Afghanistan, it is leaving behind a deadly legacy: about 800 square miles of land littered with undetonated grenades, rockets and mortar shells.
The military has vacated scores of firing ranges pocked with the explosives. Dozens of children have been killed or wounded as they have stumbled upon the ordnance at the sites, which are often poorly marked. Casualties are likely to increase sharply; the U.S. military has removed the munitions from only 3 percent of the territory covered by its sprawling ranges, officials said.
Clearing the rest of the contaminated land ' which in total is twice as big as New York City ' could take two to five years. U.S. military officials say they intend to clean up the ranges. But because of a lack of planning, officials say, funding has not yet been approved for the monumental effort, which is expected to cost $250 million.
'Unfortunately, the thinking was: 'We're at war and we don't have time for this,' ' said Maj. Michael Fuller, the head of the U.S. Army's Mine Action Center at Bagram Airfield, referring to the planning.
There are a growing number of tragedies at these high-explosives ranges.
Mohammad Yusef, 13, and Sayed Jawad, 14, grew up 100 yards from a firing range used by U.S. and Polish troops in Ghazni province. The boys' families were accustomed to the thundering explosions from military training exercises, which sometimes shattered windows in their village.
But as those blasts became less common ' a function of the U.S. and NATO withdrawal ' the boys started wandering onto the range to collect scrap metal to sell. They did not know that some U.S. explosives do not detonate on impact but can still blow up when someone touches them.
Last month, Jawad's father, Sayed Sadeq, heard a boom and ran onto the range. He spotted his son's bloodied torso.
'The left side of his body was torn up. I could see his heart. His legs were missing,' the father said.
One of the boys, it appeared, had stepped on a 40mm grenade, designed to kill anyone within five yards. Both teens died.
'If the Americans believe in human rights, how can they let this happen?' Sadeq said.
Since 2012, the United Nations' Mine Action Coordination Center of Afghanistan has recorded 70 casualties in and around U.S. or NATO firing ranges or bases, and the pace of the incidents has been quickening. But the statistics do not paint a complete picture; The Washington Post found 14 casualties not included in the U.N. data, Yusef and Jawad among them.
Most of the victims were taking their animals to graze, collecting firewood or searching for scrap metal. Of the casualties recorded by the United Nations, 88 percent were children.
'We are anxious that the problem has arisen just as ISAF is leaving,' said Abigail Hartley, director of the U.N. mine center, referring to the U.S.-led International Security Assistance Force. 'It would have been much better to have had it addressed during the last eight years.'
Costly, time-consuming task
Top U.S. military officials say they intend to remove the explosives from the firing ranges.
'It will take time and expense to complete this work, but it's critical to the safety of the Afghan people and it is the right thing to do,' said Edward Thomas, a spokesman for Gen. Martin Dempsey, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
But even if Congress approves the hundreds of millions of dollars in cleanup costs, it will be extremely complicated to remove the munitions.
The U.S. military shuttered more than half of its 880 bases in Afghanistan and withdrew the bulk of its troops before crafting a plan for removal of the unexploded ordnance, said one American official, speaking on the condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to comment on the matter. Some of the ranges that are peppered with explosives were closed as long ago as 2004. Now there are fewer service members to help conduct surveys. And in some areas, there are no U.S. troops to provide security.
'There are less people to identify sites,' the U.S. official said. 'And then if you decide you want to do the right thing and get them out there, how do you do it? Who protects them?'
In recent months, a U.S. military team was tapped to determine which ranges were causing the most casualties and where the bulk of unexploded ordnance remained. If the funding comes through, a multi-year clearance effort could begin this fall.
Senior U.S. military officials have said little publicly about the problem.
Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr., the top U.S. commander in Afghanistan, said in a news conference last month that 'taking care of all the unexploded ordnance' would consume about three months. But U.S. officials said later that Dunford was referring to the time it takes to remove ordnance from American bases ' not from the high-explosives ranges where civilians are being wounded or killed.
U.S. and NATO forces have used 240 high-explosives ranges in the 12-year-old war, some of which are the size of cities. The main range in the southern province of Helmand, for example, is 120 square miles, nearly twice the size of Washington.
About half those ranges will be transferred to the Afghan army. About 40 ranges belonged to other members of the international coalition, and those countries will have to determine whether to clear them. The remaining 73 facilities in need of cleanup total about 800 square miles, U.S. officials say.
The ranges were used not only for target practice with grenades and mortar shells but also for other exercises, sometimes involving helicopters shooting rockets. The sites have also been used to detonate caches of captured explosive material.
U.S. officials estimate that each range has thousands of undetonated explosives. Last year, contractors removed 32,000 pieces of ordnance in a 60-square-mile area ' the only stretch cleared so far.
Some of the ammunition, like the egg-size 40mm grenades, which are shot from hand-held launchers, do not detonate on impact because they have mechanical problems or land on a sandy surface. They can remain volatile for years.
'You're never going to have an end to civilian casualties until these ranges are cleared,' Fuller said. His team surveys the U.S. ranges and leads cleanup efforts.
Because Afghanistan is not a signatory to the U.N. Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, U.S. officials say they are not legally obligated to clear any of the unexploded ordnance.
Heavily mined nation
Even before the U.S. military arrived in 2001, Afghanistan was the most heavily mined country in the world. When the Soviets withdrew in 1989 after a 10-year occupation, they left about 20 million pieces of unexploded ordnance scattered nationwide. The munitions have killed and wounded thousands of children. The U.S. government has helped fund efforts to clear those devices, a massive project expected to be completed in 2023.
The firing ranges aren't the only places where U.S. military explosives may be lying undetonated. There are 331 known sites of battles against the Taliban where some American ordnance probably remains, especially from airstrikes. U.S. officials say they will not attempt to clear those sites.
'We're probably never going to be able to find those [munitions], because who knows where they landed,' said another U.S. official who also spoke on the condition of anonymity.
The United Nations says a more robust effort to clear those sites is necessary.
'The battles happened in areas where people live, work and attempt to earn their livelihoods. The contamination needs to be addressed,' Hartley said.
In response to reports of civilian casualties, the U.S. military has posted additional barricades around some firing ranges. But American officials have refused to construct fencing, which they said would be prohibitively expensive and probably ineffective.
The officials say impoverished Afghan children would find a way onto the ranges no matter what, to collect scrap metal that can be sold for about 10 cents per pound.
Outside Bagram Airfield, a U.S. military facility near Kabul, children can be seen every day wandering through a massive firing range at the base of a mountain. Some nomadic families have even set up tents inside the firing range.
'There's no other place for us to bring our sheep,' said Mohammad Raz Khan, 54, noting that the range was the only grassland around. 'Every time my sons leave the tent, I worry and worry.'
The land near the range is owned by the Afghan government and distributed to recently returned refugees or internally displaced families. In the small homes built in the area, windows shattered by blasts from the firing range are held together by tape.
Although there are concrete blocks along part of the periphery of the range, there are big gaps between them.
Two months after his family moved to Bagram, Abdul Wakhil, 12, walked around the area looking for firewood and unknowingly entered the range. Thirty feet from the main road, he stepped on an explosive.
One of his legs was blown off. The other was amputated at a Kabul hospital.
He doesn't have prosthetics or a wheelchair, so he has to be carried everywhere.
'What can he do without legs?' said his brother, Abdul Mateen, 25. 'His future is hopeless.'