AND Magazine Menu

the Man Card

There's apparently no symbolism to having white guys in charge



On the cover:

Hillary Clinton
First Lady Hillary Clinton talks to reporters on Jan. 26, 1996 after testifying before a grand jury investigating Whitewater. Hillary Diane Rodham Clinton, born October 26, 1947, a US Presidential candidate for 2016, former First Lady of the United States, United States Secretary of State, serving under President Barack Obama from 2009 to 2013; a former United States Senator from New York, and more. ©2017 Associated Press

Clinton's more than her gender

Hillary Clinton

Hillary Diane Rodham Clinton, born October 26, 1947, is an American politician and former United States Senator from New York from 2001 to 2009. | Photo: hillaryclinton.com | Link | Hillary Rodham Clinton, Secretary Of State, Hillary Clinton,

Clinton's more than her gender

40.9K

Views/Shares

[Comments] I'm not the least bit surprised Trump’s opening salvo against Hillary Clinton is that she’s playing "the woman card" and claiming that "if she were a man she wouldn't get five percent of the vote." I will be very surprised if Trump ever admits that if he himself weren’t a man, five percent of the vote is more than he could ever hope for.

Trump, for example, has bragged about sleeping around so much that STDs were his "personal Vietnam." Given the double standard for male and female sexuality, that would be a career killer for a female politician. Ditto a woman who bragged about her own sexual endowment or talked as mockingly about the opposite sex as Trump often does. A woman who was half as belligerent and flamboyantly arrogant as Trump wouldn't have much of a political career either.

Nor would the Trump followers who celebrate his attitudes to woman or minorities as "political incorrectness" (a term that pretends the most cliched, most conventional sexist and racist attitudes are somehow edgy and daring) still be in his camp. People who think misogyny "is no longer an issue," as one Trumpite put it, don't seem likely supporters for a she-Trump.

And that's not even considering the built-in advantages that men still have in politics. A man's right to be the leader is generally taken for granted; a woman's is suspect. A woman's success can always be written off as "playing the woman card," an affirmative action hire, or being a slut who slept her way to the top, regardless of the truth. A woman politician's family life is subject to criticism in a way a man isn't. Sarah Palin took a ton of flak over whether she was doing a good job with her kids; radio shrink Laura Schlesinger said with children to care for Palin shouldn't be running at all. I don't anticipate a male politician getting that kind of treatment in my lifetime.

Having white men run everything still seems normal and right to a lot of people. Wayne LaPierre of the NRA dismissed Obama as a "demographically symbolic president" and said he didn't want Clinton to become another such. In LaPierre's mind there's apparently no symbolism to having an unbroken string of white guys in charge (or if there is, it's symbolism he likes).

Arguing that Clinton is only getting votes because she's a woman also ignores that she and Trup have substantial policy differences. Trump advocates discriminating against Muslims, condemns Mexican immigrants as disease-ridden rapists, calls for more torture and celebrates when his people slap around protesters (not to mention he's a birther conspiracy believer). He's a man with zero experience in government. For me those are more than enough reasons to vote against him. Likewise there are people who'll vote against Clinton because they disagree with her politics, not just because Trump has a Y chromosome.

Trump belittling his opponents seems to be his preferred strategy, alongside bragging about his own superhuman awesomeness. Even so, it's also a smart move for Trump to ignore the issues and play the man card. It's unlikely to alienate any of his followers, might attract a few more sexists, and shifts discussion away from his actual policy positions, which are toxic to a lot of people.

Is it a smart enough move to win? I hope not. But I guess we'll find out in about six months.

Hillary


Fraser Sherman

Fraser Sherman, : Having graduated college with a degree in biology, no interest in grad school, and no interest in a science career, Fraser Sherman decided he’d try writing. It turned out he liked it. And he was even reasonably good at it. Over the next couple of decades, he sold articles to Newsweek, The Writer, Dragon Magazine (yes he played D&D. Want to make something out of it?), Air & Space and more specialized markets such as Painting and Wallcovering and Gulf Coast Condo Owner. Because he wanted... (more...)